Chapter 8
Who winslocallyin Google Search, Google Maps and AI?
I checked who a buyer sees when they search for cybersecurity services with the name of their city in one of 28 cities. In Google Search, cybersecurity firms from the same state hold only 1.7% of the spots in the top ten results in a typical city. Most spots go to national firms with pages for many cities. Google Maps shows firms with an address in the area, so a national firm without an office in the city does not appear there. Firms in the study hold 18.5% of the spots in Google Maps, and the rest go to other local businesses. ChatGPT and Perplexity recommend only 16% of firms in the study.
- 1.7%of top 10 spots in Google Search go to cybersecurity firms from the same state
- 18.5%of Google Maps spots go to the same firms
- 13.2%of top 10 spots in Google Search go to job boards
- 16%of firms in the study are recommended by ChatGPT or Perplexity
- In the typical one of the 28 cities, national and out-of-region firms hold 37.9% of the spots in Google Search's top ten for buyer phrases, while cybersecurity firms from the same state hold 1.7%.
- Google treats several buyer phrases as job searches: in a typical city, job boards dominate the results for 3 phrases.
- In Google Maps, competition is local only, because Google shows firms with an address in the area. Firms in the study hold 18.5% of the spots in Google Maps, and the rest go to other local businesses, including IT firms and MSPs. Yet only 25% of firms in the study have a Google Business Profile with reviews.
- When asked about a local provider, ChatGPT and Perplexity recommend a narrow group of firms: 16% of firms in the study appear in the answers, more often those with a higher marketing rating.
- The market profile differs between states. In the table at the end of this chapter I compare all 22 states.
Who holds the local Google Search results?
In each of the 28 cities, I checked Google Search's top ten results for 26 phrases buyers use to look for cybersecurity services, combined with the city name. I assigned each result to a category. In a typical city, the largest share of spots goes to national and out-of-region firms, often with subpages for many cities (37.9%). Next come job boards (13.2%), local IT firms and MSPs (10.8%), and directories and rankings of service providers (9.7%).
Who holds Google Search's top ten for buyer phrases
% of top 10 spots, median of 28 cities
Phrases with the city name, searched with the location set to the city. Source: Google Search results, October-November 2026.
In a typical city, cybersecurity firms from the same state hold 1.7% of the spots, and firms from other states in the study hold 3.5%. A firm from another state that has a "service + city" page can therefore outrank a local firm that does not have one. A buyer who types "soc 2 consultant Atlanta" sees mainly firms that built a page for exactly that query.
What does it look like city by city?
The share of local cybersecurity firms in the results varies between cities. It is highest in Tampa (16.3%) and Raleigh (11.7%). In many cities, no local cybersecurity firm from the study appeared in the top ten for any of the phrases. This applies to smaller cities such as Hartford, Providence and Burlington, but also to Washington, Baltimore and Detroit. Washington is the region with the most cybersecurity firms in the study, yet the local results are dominated by national firms, directories and portals.
Share of cybersecurity firms from the same state in Google Search's top 10, by city
% of top 10 spots for 26 buyer phrases
Source: Google Search results, October-November 2026.
The absence of local firms in the results does not mean there is no demand. In New York, the phrases I studied are searched about 2,390 times a month in total, and in New Jersey 1,640. In smaller cities demand is lower, but so is the competition in the results, so a single well-prepared page has a better chance of ranking high.
Demand and cost per click by city
24 buyer phrases, total searches in the city and average cost per click for ads
| city | searches / mo. | CPC (weighted avg.) |
|---|---|---|
| New York | 2,390 | $90 |
| New Jersey | 1,640 | $67 |
| Washington | 550 | $40 |
| Boston | 520 | $17 |
| Atlanta | 490 | $81 |
| Philadelphia | 390 | $35 |
| Columbus | 370 | $18 |
| Charlotte | 360 | $33 |
| Miami | 360 | $139 |
| Baltimore | 320 | $59 |
| Orlando | 320 | $125 |
| Tampa | 320 | $43 |
| Raleigh | 300 | $13 |
| Cleveland | 280 | $64 |
| Indianapolis | 280 | $13 |
| Northern Virginia | 270 | - |
| Pittsburgh | 270 | $29 |
| Detroit | 260 | $55 |
| Louisville | 230 | $29 |
| Richmond | 230 | - |
| Hartford | 210 | - |
| Columbia (SC) | 200 | $5 |
| Portland (ME) | 190 | $12 |
| Manchester (NH) | 180 | - |
| Providence | 180 | $36 |
| Burlington | 140 | $78 |
| Wilmington | 140 | - |
| Charleston (WV) | 120 | - |
CPC is an average weighted by search volume, calculated from the phrases for which Google Ads reports a cost. In smaller cities this is often 1-2 phrases, so the value is approximate. I excluded the phrase "mssp" and the phrase Google Ads merges with it, "managed security services provider": MSSP is also the name of a popular podcast and a Medicare program, and both phrases share one search volume that cannot be split. Source: Google Ads, October-November 2026.
Who does a small firm compete with in Google Maps?
For some phrases, Google shows a Google Maps map with several business listings above the search results. It shows firms with an address near the searcher, so a national firm without an office in the city will not take a spot here, even if it has a page for that city. Competition is purely local: in a typical city, cybersecurity firms from the study hold 18.5% of the spots, and the rest go to other local businesses, including IT firms and MSPs. According to Google, ranking in Google Maps depends on the relevance of the listing, the distance from the searcher and the firm's prominence, which is influenced by reviews among other things. An extensive website matters less here than in Google Search.
Only 25% of firms in the study have a Google Business Profile with reviews. In Google Maps, a small firm does not compete with national firms, only with its neighbors, and it does so in a place the buyer sees above the results. A profile with a dozen or so reviews is enough to stand out among them.
Who do ChatGPT and Perplexity recommend in each region?
In 28 cities, I asked ChatGPT and Perplexity the kind of questions a buyer asks, requesting local or regional firms. The answers included 3,285 recommendations. Most of them were for local and regional firms, but that follows from the question itself: I asked for exactly that kind of firm.
What matters more is which local firms AI chooses. It is a narrow group of firms about which it finds enough information online: 16% of firms in the study appear in the answers. AI recommendations go hand in hand with marketing: AI recommends 7% of firms with a marketing rating of 1-2 and 51% of firms rated 4-5 (chapter 9).
How do the states differ?
The table shows the profile of each state: the number of firms in the study, the share of firms with a marketing person, the share of firms without visible marketing, the share recommended by AI and the number of potential clients per cybersecurity firm.
| state | firms | has a marketing person | no marketing | recommended by AI | clients per firm |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Florida | 328 | 16% | 50% | 13% | 413 |
| Virginia | 254 | 15% | 60% | 13% | 233 |
| New York | 195 | 21% | 49% | 10% | 616 |
| Maryland | 155 | 11% | 63% | 12% | 259 |
| Georgia | 150 | 11% | 57% | 15% | 446 |
| North Carolina | 100 | 17% | 54% | 21% | 697 |
| New Jersey | 99 | 15% | 56% | 21% | 607 |
| Pennsylvania | 89 | 21% | 55% | 21% | 990 |
| Ohio | 84 | 17% | 44% | 25% | 956 |
| Massachusetts | 82 | 17% | 52% | 16% | 614 |
| Michigan | 78 | 14% | 51% | 15% | 829 |
| District of Columbia | 68 | 15% | 60% | 13% | 111 |
| Indiana | 45 | 16% | 53% | 24% | 1,025 |
| South Carolina | 29 | 3% | 38% | 24% | 1,141 |
| Connecticut | 27 | 30% | 59% | 26% | 935 |
| Kentucky | 15 | 13% | 60% | 27% | 1,860 |
| New Hampshire | 13 | 15% | 38% | 31% | 843 |
| Delaware | 10 | 0% | 70% | 10% | 747 |
| Rhode Island | 10 | 30% | 40% | 40% | 762 |
| Maine | 7 | 29% | 57% | 43% | 1,447 |
| West Virginia | 4 | 0% | 100% | 50% | 2,583 |
| Vermont | 2 | 0% | 50% | 100% | 2,485 |
In states with few firms, the shares can change a lot when one firm is added or removed. Clients per firm: companies with 10-499 employees according to the US Census Bureau (CBP 2022). Source: elevate41 study, October-November 2026.
Local Google Search results in this industry do not belong to local firms. They belong to firms that built pages for local queries, even if their headquarters are hundreds of miles away. For a firm that lives on referrals in its region, this is a risk: a new client from its own city may first land with a competitor from another state.
At the same time, being local is an advantage a national firm cannot copy. Google Maps, reviews from clients in the region and a presence at local events are places where a small firm can win without a large budget.
Michał Holub, elevate41
What to do
Below are three steps for each size group.
Business Profile and reviews
Complete your Google Business Profile
Category, services, service area, photos and current hours. Filling out the profile takes an hour, and it affects ranking in Google Maps.
Ask every client for a review
A review request after the project ends, with a direct link to the form. A dozen or so reviews make a firm stand out from the competition in Google Maps.
Check the results for your own phrases
It is worth typing your main service with your city name into Google Search and checking who holds the top ten, and whether a firm from another state is among them.
Pages for services and cities
Build a page for each key service with the city name
A description of the service for clients from a given city or region, with local examples and requirements, for example NYDFS regulations for financial firms in New York or CMMC requirements for US Army suppliers around Washington.
Get into "best firms in [city]" rankings
Rankings and directories take spots in the results and are a source for AI answers. It is worth checking which of them appear for buyer phrases.
Set up a Business Profile for each office
A firm with offices in several cities can have a separate profile for each of them.
Regions with the least competition
Compare regions
The state table shows where there are the most potential clients per cybersecurity firm, and where competition in the results is weakest.
Build pages for regions where you already have clients
A list of current clients by state and city shows where the firm already has references that can be used on a local page.
Measure visibility in each region
Once a quarter, it is worth checking rankings for the main phrases in each important city, as well as AI answers to questions about a provider in that city.
Questions for your own firm
- Who shows up in Google Search when we type our service with the name of our city?
- Are we in Google Maps, and how many reviews do we have compared with the competition?
- Does ChatGPT mention our firm when asked about a provider of our service in our city?
Methodology
How I studied regional competition
- Cities
- 28 cities, at least one in each state in the study
- 26 buyer phrases with the city name, searched with the location set to the city; Google Search's top ten results and the Google Maps map with business listings shown above the results
- Result categories
- firms in the study (from the same state and from other states), firms from the candidate list outside the study group, job boards, directories, social media, software vendors, other
- AI
- questions about a service provider in a given city asked to ChatGPT and Perplexity; recommended firms assigned a type (local, regional, national)
- Demand
- monthly search volume for 24 of the 26 phrases in each city (excluding MSSP phrases, see above); cost per click as an average weighted by search volume (Google Ads)